Think back to high school geometry. Two pints define a line, three points or elements define an arc. This is basically the concept of Minim Control. I have discussed in previous posts about my frustration with my bretheren surveyor whom believe that every survey starts at the section corner. My hat is off to Brian Dalager and his efforts to bring the surveying profession GDACS. However I am sure that Mr. Dalager is sharing a similar feeling as Alfred Noble. How could something so powerful be so destructive? Well like any tool; if used improperly it can be dangerous.
The concept of minimum control is simple. If you are attempting to replace a lost property corner you calculate your way in from THE CLOSEST acceptable evidence that controls the calculated position. Think about lot surveys. If your missing a lot corner you don't replace it be surveying your way in from the sections corner that controls the subdivision (or at least you didn't until GDACS made it possible). It was normal procedure to up and down the street adjacent to the lot and look for monumentation. Or in many cases the best available evidence of the lot corner's location.
The dirty little secret is you can't locate and monument a boundary without seeing it. GIS based calculations are great tools for establishing search areas. THEY ARE NOT boundary determinations. Calculating search areas be using GIS and GDACS is a great place to start. However I am seeing more and more the these are being used as the solution. Evidence on the ground will rule the day. Calculations to the Nth decimal place will only prove you are EXACTLY wrong.
Thursday, March 20, 2014
Monday, March 17, 2014
Well I guess....
its time for me to consider whether or not there is any point to striving to make the land surveying profession any better. Apparently I was under the mistaken belief that the purpose of a professional organization was to promote the betterment and development of the profession. I guess what we are really supposed to do; is have meetings and discuss stuff so we can feel better about ourselves without actually doing anything. Silly me.....
Thursday, January 23, 2014
Philosophical Dilemma
There has been a lot of back and forth about revising the minimum standards. There has been a great deal of effort made to revise the ABSMS by a group of surveyors from all over the state. Their efforts are to be applauded. The current standards leave much to be desired and were an attempt to fix a problem they weren't equipped to fix.
I have begun to think that maybe minimum standards for our practice is the wrong approach. Maybe we should think about a "Manual of Surveying Instructions for the Private Land within the State of Arizona". Much like the template of the BLM Manual. I envision it to be structured like this:
Chapter 1 - Authorities
State Board of Technical Registration Rules and Statutes
Chapter 2 - County Subdivisions
County Subdivision Statutes
Chapter 3 - City Subdivisions
City Subdivision Statutes
Chapter 4 - Dependent Resurveys & Independent Resurveys
Subdivisions
Public Land Survey System
Tracts, Mineral Claims, Special Surveys
Chapter 5 - Platting
General requirements for platting
County Recorder Requirements
Chapter 6 - Field Notes / Legal Descriptions
General Construction of legal descriptions
Chapter 7 - Easements and Right of Ways
Chapter 8 - Control Surveying
Chapter 9 - Topographic mapping
Chapter 10 - Definitions
Chapter 11 - Index of Case Law.
Wouldn't a manual serve our purpose to educated better than a "minimum standard"?
I have begun to think that maybe minimum standards for our practice is the wrong approach. Maybe we should think about a "Manual of Surveying Instructions for the Private Land within the State of Arizona". Much like the template of the BLM Manual. I envision it to be structured like this:
Chapter 1 - Authorities
State Board of Technical Registration Rules and Statutes
Chapter 2 - County Subdivisions
County Subdivision Statutes
Chapter 3 - City Subdivisions
City Subdivision Statutes
Chapter 4 - Dependent Resurveys & Independent Resurveys
Subdivisions
Public Land Survey System
Tracts, Mineral Claims, Special Surveys
Chapter 5 - Platting
General requirements for platting
County Recorder Requirements
Chapter 6 - Field Notes / Legal Descriptions
General Construction of legal descriptions
Chapter 7 - Easements and Right of Ways
Chapter 8 - Control Surveying
Chapter 9 - Topographic mapping
Chapter 10 - Definitions
Chapter 11 - Index of Case Law.
Wouldn't a manual serve our purpose to educated better than a "minimum standard"?
Friday, December 20, 2013
Lesson Learned
Being Chairman of APLS has taught me something. Even the best of intentions can be resisted if the other side feels shut out. I have come to realize that APLS is NOT structured for all of its members to agree on everything. No matter how bad I want us to. So from this point forward I am not going to hammer my opinion. I will offer my point of view and if you agree so be it if you disagree so be it. If you want to talk about it we can. However I won't be arguing to change any point of view. I will simply offer mine and listen you to yours.
Surveying Stuff......
I have been spending the last 2 months marking and posting national forest boundary. I love this work. Being out in the woods; the physical exertion; and the recovery of 100 year old HES corners. On one particular job the Boundary was a considerable distance inside a landowners fence. So we made contact and myself and the landowner looked for the HES corner. She kept looking around the fence and I crawled into a manzanita and there it was. I cleared the brush and showed her the chiseled "WC 8 HES ...." on the face of the sandstone. She became very angry. After several minutes of discourse she ask me to vacate the property. So we did. As we were leaving she said and I quote "F#$%ing rocks; I thought surveyors used satellites"; I am still laughing about that.
Merry Christmas ALL.
Surveying Stuff......
I have been spending the last 2 months marking and posting national forest boundary. I love this work. Being out in the woods; the physical exertion; and the recovery of 100 year old HES corners. On one particular job the Boundary was a considerable distance inside a landowners fence. So we made contact and myself and the landowner looked for the HES corner. She kept looking around the fence and I crawled into a manzanita and there it was. I cleared the brush and showed her the chiseled "WC 8 HES ...." on the face of the sandstone. She became very angry. After several minutes of discourse she ask me to vacate the property. So we did. As we were leaving she said and I quote "F#$%ing rocks; I thought surveyors used satellites"; I am still laughing about that.
Merry Christmas ALL.
Monday, December 2, 2013
When to ignore a monument accessory
I have been working on several posting jobs for the forest service. I have been noticing something in the Payson area that I did not expect. The bearing trees when measured from side center or face (more on that later) do fit the record call. The BT is there the stone is there; the bearing and distance is questionable.
So when I move to another HES corner; the stone is missing. There is a fence corner an one of the BT's of record. Also the HES was subdivided. First I checked the BT to the fence corner and it was close. Within a trash can lid. The lot corners I recovered all pointed to the fence post with a probable area of about a quarter. Well the answer was obvious;..........................
I used to be of the frame of mind that the manual was gospel and there was no deviation. Here lately I have discovered that subsequent lot corner may be a better accessory than a bearing tree.
More about the side center vs. face of blaze. In some circles this oddity is well known. Most surveyors under 50 don't know that in many parts of Arizona; mineral surveyors were also contracting with the forest service and GLO. In so doing it is not uncommon to find bearing trees on HES corners that are measured to the face of the blaze. This is the rule for mineral surveys; however for PLSS work; the side center is the rule.
In my case neither worked so I noted it and moved on...
So when I move to another HES corner; the stone is missing. There is a fence corner an one of the BT's of record. Also the HES was subdivided. First I checked the BT to the fence corner and it was close. Within a trash can lid. The lot corners I recovered all pointed to the fence post with a probable area of about a quarter. Well the answer was obvious;..........................
I used to be of the frame of mind that the manual was gospel and there was no deviation. Here lately I have discovered that subsequent lot corner may be a better accessory than a bearing tree.
More about the side center vs. face of blaze. In some circles this oddity is well known. Most surveyors under 50 don't know that in many parts of Arizona; mineral surveyors were also contracting with the forest service and GLO. In so doing it is not uncommon to find bearing trees on HES corners that are measured to the face of the blaze. This is the rule for mineral surveys; however for PLSS work; the side center is the rule.
In my case neither worked so I noted it and moved on...
Monday, November 4, 2013
Arizona Professional Land Surveyors and You
For those that don't know I am the Chairman of APLS. As the chairman I have assumed the role as the figure head of this organization. I have been continuously involved with APLS for 28 years. I am writing this as a means of getting the word out about APLS.
APLS was chartered as an organization of surveying professionals who sought to make the profession of Land Surveying better. Having said that I think we can all agree that some in the profession will not always agree with the direction has has been going. First with CEUs and now the revisions to the minimum standards.
I believe it is important for everyone to remember that although we all may not agree on the particular route APLS may take in the betterment of the profession. The end game is to make things better for the practicing surveyor in Arizona. At the moment the surveying profession is beset with several challenges that lie ahead. Recently the SBTR let us know that they intend to refine the definition of surveying in the state. APLS and the SBTR may not agree on all positions; we as APLS has tried to act as a single sounding board for what surveyors would like to see. Again some don't agree with the route APLS is taking but I think the majority agree that the current state of affairs is less than what is desired.
What the practicing surveyor needs to know is that membership is strictly voluntary and as a member you can influence how APLS policy will answer these challenges. It would be nice if all practicing land surveyors joined but that is not reality. So many will strike out on their own and voice opinions to the SBTR. To them I say good luck and God's speed. However it would be nice if we all came together as one voice and spoke from a position of strength to the SBTR. This is where I believe the chapters can make a real difference. If the chapters were to open their meetings up to non-members then the non-member could see we do not act under the cover of darkness but out in the open. Together we can accomplish the goals we all agree on. On the issues we don't agree on we can at least have an educated debate and clarify what issues are important.
APLS was chartered as an organization of surveying professionals who sought to make the profession of Land Surveying better. Having said that I think we can all agree that some in the profession will not always agree with the direction has has been going. First with CEUs and now the revisions to the minimum standards.
I believe it is important for everyone to remember that although we all may not agree on the particular route APLS may take in the betterment of the profession. The end game is to make things better for the practicing surveyor in Arizona. At the moment the surveying profession is beset with several challenges that lie ahead. Recently the SBTR let us know that they intend to refine the definition of surveying in the state. APLS and the SBTR may not agree on all positions; we as APLS has tried to act as a single sounding board for what surveyors would like to see. Again some don't agree with the route APLS is taking but I think the majority agree that the current state of affairs is less than what is desired.
What the practicing surveyor needs to know is that membership is strictly voluntary and as a member you can influence how APLS policy will answer these challenges. It would be nice if all practicing land surveyors joined but that is not reality. So many will strike out on their own and voice opinions to the SBTR. To them I say good luck and God's speed. However it would be nice if we all came together as one voice and spoke from a position of strength to the SBTR. This is where I believe the chapters can make a real difference. If the chapters were to open their meetings up to non-members then the non-member could see we do not act under the cover of darkness but out in the open. Together we can accomplish the goals we all agree on. On the issues we don't agree on we can at least have an educated debate and clarify what issues are important.
Friday, September 27, 2013
What is considered good research?
I have been to countless seminars; classes, and lectures; that all said that the survey starts with research. Going to the Recorders/Clerks office and pulling deeds and surveys. With this in mind; how in the hell did the Assessor's Tax Parcel Identification Number become the replacement. I will stipulate that the assessor's office can be a good place to start research. HOWEVER, the assessor's office is not the only place to do the research.
I have been seeing a trend that where records of survey have been citing the assessors parcel number as the basis of their research. Really? What happens when the number changes? There is no short cut to doing the research. Do it write or don't do it at all.
Viva La SALSA
I have been seeing a trend that where records of survey have been citing the assessors parcel number as the basis of their research. Really? What happens when the number changes? There is no short cut to doing the research. Do it write or don't do it at all.
Viva La SALSA
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)